Goodreads Review: Tithe
Tithe by Holly Black
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
Have you ever read a novel and wished you’d found it sooner? It might seem strange, but even though I’m a frequent consumer of YA, I rarely find myself wishing I’d read a book when I was a teenager. Usually, I’m just glad for the experience; many YA writers craft immersive worlds and likable characters so skillfully that their works feel relevant despite the fact that I’m 26 years old. And it’s not quite that I felt I was too old for Holly Black’s Tithe, the story of a New Jersey teenager who learns of her faery nature when she’s used as a pawn in the war between the Seelie and Unseelie Courts.
No, instead I simply felt that Tithe would have struck a chord with me as a teenager, that it would have been incredibly relevant had I read it upon its release in 2002, when I was eighteen, rather than eight years later. Reading it now, as a grown-up, I mostly just felt nostalgic.
Black describes the world of sixteen-year-old Kaye with surprising honesty and grit. Kaye lives in a magical land that I haven’t often seen described in books, and certainly not with such accuracy: it’s the world of my youth, New Jersey at the start of the twenty-first century. There are ravers and punk boys and long, emotionally complicated nights in diners. There are gay boys who love anime. There’s the boardwalk of what I was sure must have been Asbury Park, abandoned and creepy and vivid. And, true-to-form, there’s Kaye, an honestly written heroine if I’ve ever seen one. Kaye’s a bit weird–she had fairies as imaginary friends since she was a kid–and definitely imperfect. She can’t help but seduce her best friend’s boyfriend. She gets her other friends into trouble. She’s flawed, but, dammit, she’s honest. As I read Tithe I couldn’t help but feel that I knew Kaye–she’s just about every teenage girl, complicated and conflicted. In short, she was terrific.
As were most of the supporting characters here: Corny, Kaye’s companion, one of the most realistically rendered gay friends I’ve ever seen in fiction. Corny isn’t a magical and perfect gay boy a la Mercedes Lackey, but instead a complex and complete person in his own right. Likewise, Roiben, Kaye’s otherworldly love interest, a sexy stoic with problems and a life beyond Kaye’s.
Unfortunately, the plotting of the novel doesn’t quite live up to the promise of the characters. Black takes us a long time to get us to the central conflict, and Kaye’s episodic explorations through the faery world just weren’t as interesting to me as her adventures in the in the real world. Still, there’s a lot worth exploring here–particularly if you’ve ever found magic in the magical kingdom known as New Jersey.
Phoebe
Phoebe is a 20-something writer who lives in New York State with her husband and cat. She is a dork, not a geek or a nerd.
Her debut novel, Starglass, will be released from Simon and Schuster Books for Young Readers in Summer 2013.
One comment
I definitely find myself thinking sometimes, “This book is kind of meh but I’d find it so romantic/sexy/brilliant” if I’d read it waaay back when. Can’t think of any examples right now, but it has happened, definitely.