On Complicated Friendships
I’m trying to stick with the resolution I made one post down where I said that I wouldn’t query at two a.m. My fingers are feeling pretty twitchy, but my real (important, vital) writing is flagging thanks to the late hour, so I figured I’d write here about something I’ve been thinking about lately.
I stumbled across a review series called “The Sparkle Project” by LJ user Ceilidh-ann a few weeks ago. If you haven’t read these cutting and pretty much flat-out awesome reviews of in-the-vein-of-Twilight YA, I urge you to go take a look. I’ll wait!
Terrific, right? In her reviews, Ceilidh-ann uses the following “Sparkle bingo checklist” to evaluate a book:
- Where the fuck is the plot?
- Personality free hero/heroine.
- Purple prose.
- Mythology fail.
- Lack of real villain.
- Unlikeable/dull lead characters.
- Description fail.
- Stalking = love.
- Complete lack of romantic development.
- Other women = sluts/bitches.
- Special snowflake!
- Passing family/lack of parental interaction.
- Beauty = best thing ever!
Books that have many of these things are, you see, quite sparkly.
I actually found this checklist really helpful in editing SEAS RUN DRY. It was a useful metric for how cliché I was being, and where I fell victim to the worst sort of paranormal romance tropes. I actually ended up tightening these flaws up quite a bit (Irene is much less of a special snowflake now, and her relationship with her family is clarified and better developed, f’rinstance), the result being that early beta readers (hi, Pat!) read a much sparklier book than later betas (hi, Sean!).
I keep returning to one bullet point, though. And that’s the fact that most of the other women in the book are sluts/bitches.
I could whine to you about how I have a reason for this–Loril’s species is 90% female due to some cruel twist of nature, leading to natural competition between women. They’re also mermaids, ruthless about sex and love. They lure sailors to the water and drown them, for chrissake!
But that’s not really a sufficient excuse, you see. Because there’s a human girl, Irene’s coworker, who tries to get all grabby with Loril in a bar. And she doesn’t have a tail.
And I’ve been thinking, too, of TRIP, my current project, and how heroine Francine has a thorny relationship with her girlfriend Linda. Linda is kind of catty and cutting to her so far–a bit competitive, particularly where boys are concerned.
I want to show positive relationships between women and especially between girls. I always try to make my manuscripts pass The Bechdel Test–I want my women to talk about real things, important things, with each other, even! And that seems to be easy enough.
But the truth is that many of my own female friendships have been more Margaret Atwood than Alison Bechdel–intense, competitive, and ultimately complicated. For example, just a few weeks ago, a dear friend of mine and I were talking about high school. And she mentioned how she made fun of me because there were certain jealousies between us, a certain sort of competition. Now, as an adult, I can understand where she was coming from–and see the times when I myself was a less-than-perfect friend, in turn. At the time, though, it sure did hurt. (As I’m sure I sometimes hurt her.)
I suspect that if my friend and I had been book characters, we would have come across as bitches. Would we be tiresome, or trite, or a bad example for teenage readers? Or would we ring true, and resonate with them?
I wouldn’t dream of throwing out the baby with the bathwater–Can I tell you how much my friend and I have supported one another over the years, cried together, and listened?–but I wouldn’t want to give a saccharine picture of female friendships just for the sake of promoting a certain ideal–one that may exist, but that I’ve rarely experienced in life. I suspect the way to write the relationship between women well, like so much else, lies with honesty and detail. I just hope that I get those details right–and I don’t do my female audience, or my female characters, a disservice.
How do you approach writing about friendships between women? Is this something you think actively about when you write or when you read?




